Academics
Home >
Mass Violence in an Age of Terror, Catastrophe and the Responsibility to Protect
An interdisciplinary workshop organized by the Peace and Conflict Studies Program
Colgate University
March 30-31, 2012
Public forum
"The Future of Warfare"
A moderated community conversation with workshop participants
Colgate University Bookstore
March 30, 2012
4:00 - 5:30pm
Workshop Rationale
"War no longer exists."
- General Rupert Smith, The Utility of Force.
"With the distinction between a state of war and a state of peace thus effectively blurred, we are entering a time in which a state of peace can at the same time be a state of emergency."
- Slavoj Žižek, "Are we in a war?"
The past quarter century witnessed the primary terrain of global security shift from the international to the intra- and trans-national. Post-Cold War, mass violence has become development in reverse — the unmaking of sovereignties, economies and societies. Contemporary mass violence not only poses a direct challenge to the spread of democratic norms, it also calls into question the ability of states and international organizations to use effective military force to uphold humanitarian norms, defeat irregular armies and rehabilitate collapsed governments. Mass violence also challenges social science; scholars have struggled to keep pace with new dynamics and patterns of armed conflict that appear to defy and transgress existing conceptual schema and traditional levels of analysis.
Though understandings of late warfare have been deeply affected by the international milieu of the 1990s, the global scene has undergone immense changes during the past decade. These changes have yet to be fully appreciated when it comes to the study of mass armed violence, particularly:
-
The events of September 11, 2001, and the subsequent “war on terror”
- The refinement and attempted codification of the principles and practices of humanitarian intervention under the rubric of the “Responsibility to Protect” doctrine; and
- The ensemble of global forces converging into a potentially nonlinear and catastrophic environmental breakdown, bringing with it unknowable social, political and economic ramifications
With these changes in mind, this workshop seeks to accomplish three aims: - To offer a critical evaluation of the state of the study of armed conflict, particularly after a decade of intensive research within competing paradigms (e.g., New Wars vs Greed/Grievance).
- To assess this literature within these new and changing international contexts, one markedly different from the immediate post-Cold War reality that gave birth to the recent renaissance in the study of “civil wars.”
- Implications for democratic governance and the efficacy of military interventions will be assessed, particularly for those states most tasked with these responsibilities.
Workshop Participants:
Peace and Conflict Studies (P-CON) at Colgate:
Jacob Mundy (jmundy@colgate.edu), Assistant Professor, Workshop Co-Organizer
Stefanie Fishel (sfishel@colgate.edu), Post-Doctoral Research Fellow, Co-Organizer
David Campbell, A. Lindsay O’Connor Professor in Peace and Conflict Studies
Daniel Monk, George R. and Myra T. Cooley Professor of Peace and Conflict Studies and Professor of Geography
Nancy Ries, Associate Professor of Anthropology and Chair of Peace and Conflict Studies
Susan Thomson, Assistant Professor
Presenters
Responsibility to Protect as an Apparatus of Capture: Biopolitics and Intervention
Gossip, politics and survival in armed conflict
Caroline Holmqvist, Swedish National Defense College
New Political Spatialities in the War/Policing Nexus; The Issue of 'Strategic Communications'
Ben Meiches, Johns Hopkins University
The Responsibility to Preserve: Humanitarian Intervention and Violent Expenditure
Tin Men: Ethics, Cybernetics and the Importance of Soul
The Politiography of Late Warfare: Towards a Critique
Disappearing Violence, Eroding Boundaries: American Counterinsurgency and the Dark Arts of Networked Warfare
When the "Homeland" is a Warzone: Iraqis Writing from Positions of Exile and Displacement
Jean-François Ratelle, University of Ottawa
Micro-dynamics of Political Violence in Civil Wars: An Ethnographic-based Analysis of the North Caucasus
Kill and Be Killed: Aesthetics and the Biopolitical Subject